Default login not working on first login

I set up a new Windmill instance using the docker-compose setup and upon first login using the default login credentials

/user/login?email=admin@windmill.dev&password=changeme

/user/login?email=admin@windmill.dev&password=changeme

it throws

Invalid credentials

Invalid credentials

I have tried recreating the database

drop database windmill;
create database windmill;

drop database windmill;
create database windmill;

But still get the same error upon first login

Any ideas on what I might have done wrong or how to debug?